Head-to-Head
JOLLY RANCHER Zero Sugar Original Flavors Hard Candy vs Jolly Ranchers
It's a Jolly Rancher family feud! We're putting the new JOLLY RANCHER Zero Sugar Original Flavors Hard Candy up against the legendary original Jolly Ranchers to see if ditching sugar means ditching flavor. Both come from The Hershey Company, both pack high-intensity fruit punch — but the trade-offs might surprise you.
Allergen Information — Both Products
⚠️ Contains:
⚠️ BOTH products contain SOY (via soy lecithin). Both are manufactured by The Hershey Company in facilities that process milk, peanuts (Zero Sugar only mentions peanuts), tree nuts, wheat, and eggs — cross-contamination risk applies to both. Both are choking hazards for children under 4–5 years old. The Zero Sugar version contains sugar alcohols (Isomalt) that may cause gas, bloating, and diarrhea — the packaging carries a laxative-effect warning, and children's smaller digestive systems may be more sensitive. Always check current packaging for the most up-to-date allergen and ingredient information.
The Hershey Company
JOLLY RANCHER Zero Sugar Original Flavors Hard Candy
7
Sweet
4
Sour
Low Mess
Mess
The Hershey Company
Jolly Ranchers
7
Sweet
5
Sour
Some Mess
Mess
Head-to-Head Scores
| Category | JOLLY RANCHER Zero Sugar Original Flavors Hard Candy | Jolly Ranchers | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flavor | 9 | 9 | Both deliver bold, high-intensity fruit flavor with a sweetness rating of 7/10 — the Zero Sugar version is shockingly close to the original, with only a tiny aftertaste holding it back. |
| Sourness/Tang | 4 | 5 | The original Jolly Ranchers edge ahead with a slightly tangier, more sour punch (5 vs 4), giving flavors like Green Apple that extra cheek-tingling kick. |
| Texture & Durability | 7 | 9 | The originals are rock-hard and dissolve slowly, lasting through a whole car ride; the Zero Sugar version is more brittle and cracks apart faster due to its Isomalt-based formula. |
| Mess Factor | 9 | 7 | Zero Sugar earns a 'low' mess rating while the originals rate 'medium' — the original gets sticky and glues to teeth if bitten, making it messier overall. |
| Value | 5 | 8 | At $5.49–$6.34 for a 6.1 oz bag, Zero Sugar costs 2–3x more per ounce than the originals at $3.49–$4.97 — a significant price gap for a similar candy experience. |
| Kid Appeal | 8 | 9 | Kids love both, but the originals win for lasting longer, having more flavor variety (5 flavors vs 4), and no aftertaste — Zero Sugar is still a hit but the slight differences add up. |
If you already love Jolly Ranchers, the zero sugar version is surprisingly close to the real deal — the flavors are bold and fruity and the only real bummer is a tiny aftertaste and they break a little easier. Just don't eat a ton at once or your stomach might not be too happy with you!
Jolly Ranchers are a classic treat that delivers on flavor and value — individually wrapped pieces offer built-in portion control, and one candy keeps a kid occupied for several minutes. The tradeoffs are real though: all added sugar, artificial dyes, and a genuine dental risk if chewed, so keep these away from kids with braces and treat them as an occasional indulgence rather than an everyday snack.
The Verdict
Jolly Ranchers Wins
The original Jolly Ranchers take the crown here — they last longer, deliver slightly tangier flavor, cost significantly less, and earned a rock-solid 4.5 rating that's hard to beat. That said, the Zero Sugar version is a genuinely impressive alternative for families managing sugar intake, scoring a full 5/5 in its own review for faithfully capturing the Jolly Rancher experience. If sugar is a concern, go Zero Sugar and enjoy; if not, the classic is still king.
Read the full reviews: JOLLY RANCHER Zero Sugar Original Flavors Hard Candy · Jolly Ranchers
Philly's Snacks may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.